Updated hours for 2026!
620 Ridge Road, Webster, NY, USA
Open Thur 9am-3pm, Fri 9am-5pm, Sat 10am-3pm
about FIRST KNIGHT COINS & COLLECTABLES
ABOUT JOE MCMAHON
In a land far, far away (…ahem….Springville, NY), a young Joe McMahon was bitten by the coin bug. His love for coins continues to this day. In order to get his regular “coin fix”, Joe combined his day job as a neon glass bender and sign maker with a coin shop in the perfect location – 620 Ridge Road in Webster, NY.
Outside of coins, Joe is the owner of a successful Rochester sign manufacturing company, E-lite Neon Signs, LLC, as well as First Knight Racing, a local multisport organization (and yes, if you have a broken neon sign, you can bring that to us too).
Reach out to us to set up an appointment for a free coin appraisal and let Joe the Coin Nerd paw through your coins. He will take the time to educate you on what you have and what it’s worth and make you an offer if you would like to sell.