620 Ridge Road, Webster, NY, USA
Open Wed & Thur 9am-2pm, Fri 9am-5pm, Sat 9am-3pm
Free coin appraisal hours on Fridays and Saturdays, or by appointment
Welcome to First Knight coins & collectables
Welcome to First Knight Coins and Collectables, where passion for coins meets 40+ years of expertise!
Got a coin collection but unsure what it's worth? We’re here to help!
At First Knight Coins and Collectables, we offer free, no-obligation open coin appraisals on Fridays and Saturdays to give you a clear picture of the value of your coins. Whether you’ve inherited a collection or just started gathering, our experienced numismatists will take the time to evaluate each piece and share their insights.
So bring your coins, chat with us over a cup of coffee, and let’s explore the world of coins together—whether you're looking to buy, sell, or simply learn more about your collection!
Let’s unlock the hidden value of your collection with our Numismatist coin dealer!
Coin Appraisal Hours
We have general retail hours Wednesday through Saturday.
Open coin appraisals by Joe are offered:
- Fridays: Noon-5:00pm
- Saturdays: 10:00am to 3:00pm
- Or by appointment. Please contact us if you would like to meet with Joe at a time other than his open coin appraisal hours listed above.
Any unusual changes to store hours will be posted on our Facebook page.
Contact Us
Send us a note using the form to connect with us regarding your coin appraisal needs! We will respond ASAP to coordinate a time for you to meet with our coin dealer during Friday or Saturday open coin appraisals, or by appointment at your convenience.
UPDATED 3/25/25 - Store Hours
Open today | 09:00 am – 02:00 pm |
If you would like have your coins appraised outside of our normal hours, send us a text to coordinate a day and time that works best.